The Disadvantages Of Metal Roofs

Katelyn Lewis • September 21, 2022

Metal roofs come with lots of benefits – they’re environmentally friendly, super durable, and last 3-4x their asphalt shingle roof counterparts – which is why we’re seeing a rise in homeowners opting for this roofing material.


But what are the disadvantages of a metal roof?

Metal roofs are more expensive upfront. Metal roofs cost between 3-5 times as much as their asphalt shingle roof counterparts. The higher cost is due to the higher level of skills required to install these roofing systems correctly, as well as the material itself. However, metal roofing systems will last at least 50 years if well maintained – way longer than their shingle counterparts, which typically last between 17 to 25 years. From this perspective, a metal roof is a better investment if you plan to stay in your home for a long time.


Metal roofs are slippery, especially when wet.
This disadvantage comes into play if/when you try to climb on your roof or clean your gutters. While helpful for sliding snow off during the winter, the slipperiness of these roofs can be dangerous for homeowners to scale. Take caution and wear a good pair of boots with grip if you’re trying to access your metal roof. 


Metal roofs can be difficult to repair.
If, for example, your metal roof sustains storm damage, the difficulty of the repair and skill required to do it correctly will make it more expensive to repair than an asphalt shingle roof repair. 



Metal roofs can be dented.
Though metal panels today are designed to withstand decades of severe weather, large hail or fallen tree limbs and branches can dent them. This disadvantage depends on the type of metal roof installed, too. Aluminum and copper metal roofs, for example, are more susceptible to dents as they’re softer metals than steel metal roofs. 


Finally, let’s debunk the noise factor.
People often wonder if metal roofs are noisier than other roofing materials during a heavy rain or thunderstorm. While some may list this noise factor as a “con,” a properly insulated metal roof – and well-insulated attic space, too – will minimize any noise you hear from a passing storm. And, for some homeowners, the sounds they hear during a rainstorm from their metal roofs can be soothing. It really depends on your preference!


While we’ve culled together these five disadvantages of metal roofs, these cons are far outweighed by the pros of having a metal roof. Metal roofs are more environmentally friendly, with most made from at least 50% recycled metals and 100% recyclable upon their removal. They also last for at least 50 years, meaning less waste over time. They are energy efficient, reflecting the sun’s heat away from your home year-round but especially during the summer. And they are super stylish and versatile, with more than 100 colors of metal roofs available.


Interested in a metal roof? Need to replace your roof? Call us today at 804-258-6300 or click the button below to schedule a complimentary assessment.

New Button
Photo of RETEX’s Mark Scarpino relaxing in a pool tube during our 2025 RETEX team pool party.
By Katelyn Lewis July 29, 2025
We're so happy we got the chance to hang with our team and their families at our RETEX pool party on Saturday, July 26.
RETEX roof replacement in Fredericksburg, VA 22406 with Tamko Heritage
By Katelyn Lewis July 25, 2025
This Fredericksburg homeowner reached out to RETEX in April 2025 looking for a roof replacement quote for a home he was selling by the end of the month.
RETEX's Josh Lewis holds Albus Lewis in front of a RETEX truck.
By Katelyn Lewis July 17, 2025
Josh Lewis is the leader of our mighty team orchestrating our branch management, sales, and production teams while planning for our company’s future growth.
RETEX Cedar shake roof replacement in Fredericksburg, VA 22401, December 2024.
By Katelyn Lewis July 11, 2025
This Fredericksburg homeowner reached out to RETEX in October 2024 for an estimate for replacing his shake roof with natural cedar shakes.
Chris dressed as a bad contractor
By Katelyn Lewis July 9, 2025
While some of these contractors might be reputable, others — known as “storm chasers” — follow severe weather events, hoping to cash in on vulnerable homeowners.
Fireworks for 4th of July.
By Katelyn Lewis July 4, 2025
We will be closed on Friday, July 4, and Saturday, July 5, in observance of the holiday.
RETEX crew installs windows on North Chesterfield VA home.
By Derrick Tittsworth July 2, 2025
Online pricing calculators and AI tools are great for ballpark numbers, but they don’t know the local labor market and specific window options for your home.
Repair Team Bravo (Scott Gibson and Patrick Nelson) stand in front of a RETEX Repair van.
By Katelyn Lewis June 26, 2025
Scott Gibson serves on our Repair Team Bravo. Scott works with Patrick every day to repair shingle roofs and repoint chimneys and brick for our customers. Scott’s been with RETEX since August 2023, and this year he and Patrick have headed our same-day repair services.
One of RETEX's crew members installing a gutter guard on a Ply Gem seamless gutter system.
By Katelyn Lewis June 25, 2025
It depends. Read the scenarios in which we recommend homeowners invest in gutter guards for their homes.
Aerial photo of Spinnaker Cove condos. RETEX replaced the shingle roofs, flat roofs, and siding.
By Katelyn Lewis June 20, 2025
Today’s Finished Roof Friday comes with a homeowner tip: Always check your home exterior contractor’s license before moving forward with any work or deposit.