Should You Tear Off & Replace Or Shingle Over Your Roof?

Katelyn Lewis • January 24, 2024

When a roof is past its prime, some homeowners consider tearing off and replacing the whole roof or adding another layer, sometimes called “reroofing,” to save money.

A during-tear-off image of a RETEX roof replacement in Midlothian, VA 23113.

Here’s why we only offer the tear-off method:


  • A new roof installed over a clean surface tends to have a longer lifespan because there are no old materials or potential issues beneath the new shingles.

  • Installing a new roof reduces the overall weight on your home's structure and prevents any moisture from being trapped between the layers, which could lead to potential issues like mold and poor energy efficiency.

  • During the tear-off process, any underlying issues with the roof deck or structure can be identified and addressed.


While tearing off the old roof and installing a new one is generally more expensive due to the labor, materials, and disposal costs involved, a new, single-layer roof will have a longer lifespan than a double-layer roof. The added weight and heat of a double-layer roof can also accelerate its wear and tear, aging it faster than a single-layer roof. Plus, double-layered roofs can look bulkier and less visually appealing than a single-layer roof.


Considering replacing your roof in 2024? Start by scheduling a free estimate with Retex – give us a call at 804-258-6300 today.

CONTACT RETEX
Hardie Plank Siding replacement in Chesterfield, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis December 17, 2025
Here are three strong reasons to consider this fiber cement siding option for your home's exteriors.
Image of snacks and drinks provided to Beulah Elementary in Chesterfield, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis December 16, 2025
Between Richmond, Charlottesville, and Fredericksburg, we’ve spread love and given a pick-me-up to nearly 2,000 teachers and staff at 23 schools this fall.
Standing seam metal roof replacement in Providence Forge, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis December 12, 2025
RETEX replaced the asphalt shingles on this Providence Forge home in July 2024 with a standing seam metal roof in “ivy green” color.
RETEX's Andy Connor.
By Katelyn Lewis December 11, 2025
Join us in wishing a happy birthday to Andy Connor, one of our fantastic exterior experts,
Chimney repointing in North Chesterfield, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis December 9, 2025
Chimney repointing fixes the mortar seals between the bricks of your chimney.
Roof replacement with Tamko Stormfighter shingles.
By Katelyn Lewis December 3, 2025
Most asphalt shingles require warmer temperatures to install safely, but TAMKO’s StormFighter shingles are designed for lower-temperature installs.
RETEX standing seam metal roof replacement in Richmond, 23222.
By Katelyn Lewis December 2, 2025
Richmond homeowner Joy Shepperson reached out to RETEX in October 2025 after noticing a leak down one of her home’s walls.
Group photo of RETEX employees.
By Katelyn Lewis November 29, 2025
We’re proud to be a locally owned home exterior company serving Richmond, Fredericksburg, and Charlottesville – built on craftsmanship, care, and community.
Retex team group shot.
By Katelyn Lewis November 27, 2025
We’re feeling festive in light of Thanksgiving, so bare with us as we take a moment to share our thanks.
Stock image of Thanksgiving meal.
By Katelyn Lewis November 25, 2025
Our office will be closed starting Wednesday, Nov. 25, through Sunday, Nov. 30, as we take time to celebrate with our friends and family.