Should You Tear Off & Replace Or Shingle Over Your Roof?

Katelyn Lewis • January 24, 2024

When a roof is past its prime, some homeowners consider tearing off and replacing the whole roof or adding another layer, sometimes called “reroofing,” to save money.

A during-tear-off image of a RETEX roof replacement in Midlothian, VA 23113.

Here’s why we only offer the tear-off method:


  • A new roof installed over a clean surface tends to have a longer lifespan because there are no old materials or potential issues beneath the new shingles.

  • Installing a new roof reduces the overall weight on your home's structure and prevents any moisture from being trapped between the layers, which could lead to potential issues like mold and poor energy efficiency.

  • During the tear-off process, any underlying issues with the roof deck or structure can be identified and addressed.


While tearing off the old roof and installing a new one is generally more expensive due to the labor, materials, and disposal costs involved, a new, single-layer roof will have a longer lifespan than a double-layer roof. The added weight and heat of a double-layer roof can also accelerate its wear and tear, aging it faster than a single-layer roof. Plus, double-layered roofs can look bulkier and less visually appealing than a single-layer roof.


Considering replacing your roof in 2024? Start by scheduling a free estimate with Retex – give us a call at 804-258-6300 today.

CONTACT RETEX
RETEX trucks and vehicles in a line, Richmond Va.
By Katelyn Lewis September 18, 2025
Explore more than 60 big trucks and vehicles of all kinds at the 20th Annual Touch A Truck event, on Saturday, Oct. 18 at Richmond Raceway.
RETEX’s Katelyn Lewis stocked the teachers’ lounges at A.M. Davis, Robious, and Watkins Elementaries
By Katelyn Lewis September 17, 2025
RETEX’s Katelyn Lewis helped to stock the teachers’ lounges at A.M. Davis, Robious Elementary, and J.G. Watkins Elementary this week.
A RETEX employee installs Hardie Plank fiber cement siding at our new RETEX office location.
By Katelyn Lewis September 16, 2025
Our RETEX office has moved around the corner to Hull Street Rd. We've remodeled it a bit in the last month, including installing the new sign, Hardie siding and soffit, front door, and new windows on the front.
Retex replaced this Fredericksburg asphalt shingle roof in June 2024.
By Katelyn Lewis September 12, 2025
RETEX replaced this Fredericksburg asphalt shingle roof in June 2024.
RETEX replaces the siding on a home in North Chesterfield, VA.
By Katelyn Lewis September 10, 2025
If you spot any of these five signs on your home's siding, it may be time to call a siding contractor for a replacement quote.
Snacks in the teachers' lounge at Bon Air Elementary, supplied by RETEX in September 2025.
By Katelyn Lewis September 9, 2025
RETEX’s Katelyn Lewis started the RETEX Teachers’ Treats initiative to support the local teachers and staff as they work hard to educate our future leaders.
We replaced the flat roof for this Glen Allen home in August 2025.
By Katelyn Lewis September 4, 2025
Flat roofs are a common roofing option throughout Richmond, whether for a whole home or on small additions with low pitches.
RETEX
By Katelyn Lewis September 1, 2025
RETEX will be closed today in observance of the holiday, but we’re open tomorrow.
Image of RETEX's Chris Spahr in front of a RETEX truck.
By Katelyn Lewis August 31, 2025
Chris is one of our fantastic exterior experts, helping folks get clear, fair quotes on their roofs, siding, windows, and gutters.
Retex recoated the metal roof and replaced the gutters on this Stafford, VA home in May 2025.
By Katelyn Lewis August 29, 2025
Recoating metal roofs provides a less-expensive option than replacing them, with the coating sealing any leaks, cracks, and seams that natural wear-and-tear causes.